Recently I acquired three albums that made a big deal about being named one of Rolling Stones 500 greatest albums of all time! Since then I’ve become a little obsessed with this list. I remember when it came out. My roommate Pete and I had a few discussions, but I forgot about it soon after. It seems I now have more time to listen to music, so I’ve been thinking a lot about my own personal list of favorite albums. To me there are three things that make an album legendary and worthy of being called the “best”: It inspires future artists, it needs to be an pleasant experience from the first song to the last and it has to be a nice balance of talented musicianship that the masses would want to listen to (in other words no Dream Theater or Steve Vai). Also, one of the biggest beefs people have with Rolling Stones’ list is the inclusion of "greatest hits” compilations which is kind of cheating, I agree. I also think too many of Rolling Stones' selections were based on albums that had two or three really pivotal songs, while the rest of the songs on the album were sub-standard. I think a good album is allowed to have a little weird stuff between songs, but each real track should stand on its own. I think that comes from being a part of the I-pod generation and being able to put my whole music collection on shuffle. So here is my list of the top ten albums that I hope to be on my mp3 player if I get trapped in a cave and music is my only means of staying sane.
10. Loaded, The Velvet Underground- Most people rant and rave about their first album due to Andy Warhol’s contributions. I think that album is great considering the drummer only had three drums and a tambourine, the violin player only knew about seven notes and Lou Reed still did not know how to tune his guitar. “Loaded”, however is really that album that I can put in anytime anywhere and feel good.
9. The Cars, The Cars- I think The Cars were the last band that could integrate synthesizer into their music but not depend too much on it (as many future 80's bands began to do). This album is that missing link between The Who and Erasure, and I love it.
8. Mtv Unplugged in New York, Nirvana- I hated this album when it first came out. I actually traded my first copy to my friend Brandon Leavitt for some trashy old school punk rock tape. Now that I am wiser, I realize the beauty of this album. I think it is awesome that they play a Ledbelly cover, yet never play their biggest hit “Smells Like Teen Spirit”. It shows there lack of ego in there own success and there love for music that made them great. I read a story once that you were just as like likely to hear Abba on their tour bus as you were Dinosaur Jr.
7. Paranoid, Black Sabbath- Nothing but power chords, pentatonic scales and a whole lot of energy. This album is track after track of music all rockers aspire to make.
6. Exodus, Bob Marley and the Wailers- This album was made after Peter Tosh had left and Bob added “Family man” and his back-up singers. It also was made while Marley and his wife were both recovering from gun shot wounds. I think it was his best album because instead of just track after track of rebel music, he actually has a few lighter songs like one about two little birds singing sweet songs.
5. Ok Computer, Radiohead- In the later nineties, rock music was growing very stale. Grunge had taken over and all bands either sounded like Pearl Jam or Nirvana. It got so bad people began to resort back to cheesy pop like the Back Street Boys. OK Computer was the album that seemed to shake everyone up and say, hey there is more to life then loud driven music with lyrics nobody understands, there is weird ambient music with lyrics that nobody can understand.
4. Weezer (the blue album), Weezer- take the grunge invasion, remove the screaming and add vocalist that harmonize with each other and you have Weezer. Everyone laughed when I wore my blue Weezer shirt in 1998… now it’s a desired eBay product I will never part with.
3. Odessey and Oracle, The Zombies- this album was actually recorded in Abby Road studios while the Beatles were recording Sgt. Peppers. It is said that the making this album was such an exhausting process the band broke up when they saw that odessey was spelled wrong on the cover (sort of the straw that broke the camel’s back). Since there was no band to tour and promote it, it was sort of pushed aside until a radio Dj in L.A. started playing "Time of the Season". Then a bunch of counterfeit groups toured as The Zombies and the album began to achieve some initial success. Since then it has become a staple to any music lovers’ collection including Elliot Smith (who covered "Care of Cell 44"). It is the best example of perfect vocal harmonies blended with organ rock.
2. Odelay, Beck- I really think this album took the word eclectic to a new level and brought it into musician’s vocabulary. It won Beck Artist of the year in 1998 and it one of the few albums from high school that I have not turned into Hastings. It helped get us all out of the mosh pit and on to the dance floor.
1. Revolver, The Beatles- Most “best of” lists really come down to what is the best Beatles album, and rightly so. Most people think its Sergeant Peppers because many believe it ushered in a new era and because it received so much commercial success. I think the only reason it was so popular is because so many other bands had gotten a hold of “Revolver” and created and pre-era that help cushion the blow. Plus Revolver has John Lennon singing over a guitar and drum loop, a technique that has been mimicked by everyone from Michael Jackson to The Chemical Brothers.
Honorable mention: Dark side of the Moon by Pink Floyd and Soft Bulletin by The Flaming lips.
Now if I were to take out the influential part and count down my top ten most recent albums it would be
10. Foxtrot Hotel, Wilco
9. Our Ill Wills, The Shout out louds
8. Everything All the Time, Band of Horses
7. Castaways and Cutouts, The Decembrist
6. Cutes Too Narrow, The Shins
5. Trouble, Ray LaMontage
4. In Case we die, Architecture in Helsinki
3. Elephant, The White Stripes
2. The Throes, The Two Gallants
1. Dear Catastrophe Waitress, Belle and Sebastian
Honorable mention: Illinoise by Sufjan Stevens and Funeral by Arcade Fire.